Thursday, July 19, 2007

Linus, Linux and the GPLv3

What most people forget is that Free Software is a balance between the rights of the creator and the user. Anything that disturbs that balance needs to be dealt with. Both patents and DRM represent things that disturb the rights of the users in favor of the creators.

RMS is not trying to force his personal beliefs on people. You don't have to change to the GPLv3, no one does. Linus, on the other hand, is coming out and engaging in name calling. I've seen more and more of this from Linus over the past few years. I don't see him as any better than RMS, in fact, I see him as worse. To me he seems like the kind of person who, if you don't agree with him, he'll freely and publicly call you names. That doesn't seem to me to be the approach of an intelligent or reasonable person. It seems to be to be the approach of someone who's ego has gotten a little too big for his own good. Not one of the reasons Linus has yet given for his dislike of the GPLv3 has made a great deal of sense from my point of view. Linus seems unable or, possibly, unwilling to engage in a debate about this pertaining to the facts of the matter. Instead he would rather distract people from the real issues by calling RMS a fanatic and calling anyone that adopts the GPLv3 hypocrites.

He states that the GPLv3 will make it difficult for business' to use GPL'd software. This is, in fact, correct. The GPLv3 will make it more difficult for companies to restrict the rights of their users (people like you and me). The GPL was meant to protect against this type of thing. As the world evolved, the GPLv2 became inadequate due to the simple fact that many of the technologies and problems which exist now did not exist when it was drafted. It therefore, has legal holes it in nowadays that one could drive a truck through. The GPLv3 was meant to address the shortcomings and, in some cases, the lack of clarity of the GPLv2. It protects the users better and is clearer on what is and is not distribution.

If Linus wants to play name calling games, that's just fine. If, however, he wants to actually discuss the facts, he and the rest of his sycophantic followers should engage the FSF in a debate.. or, at least, they should have been more of a part of the drafting of the GPLv3 than they were... certainly... if you don't put your 2 cents into something, especially when you're invited to do so (GPLv3 comments were open to the public and, indeed, Eben Moglen publicly asked the Linux contributors to participate)... then, in my opinion, you have no cause to complain when the process is finish.

Linus and his ilk had their chance to say something and they remained silent. Why should they be listened to now?

The GNUstep project is moving to the GPLv3, as are Samba and many other Free Software projects. Linus has forgotten what Free Software is all about... a balance of individual rights. The GPLv3 is, quite honestly, the best way to proceed forward, since it addresses critical issues in the previous version. If Linus want's to think us all hypocrites, then so be it. I would submit, however, that he is the one engaging in hypocrisy. When someone can take Linux and add DRM code to it and then distribute it under the GPLv2 and get away with it, then that defeats the spirit of the GPL in the first place. Perhaps, then, it's not so much hypocrisy on Linus' part as it is a sheer lack of understanding. Perhaps he never understood the GPL in the first place.

19 comments:

Jesse Ross said...

Is GNUstep moving to GPLv3 or LGPLv3?

GregC said...

Jesse,

It's moving to both. Since the apps are GPL and the libraries are LGPL, it will be GPL/LGPL where appropriate.

GJC

chdig said...

Greg, philosophical question for you. When you wrote: "Free Software is a balance between the rights of the creator and the user. Anything that disturbs that balance needs to be dealt with. Both patents and DRM represent things that disturb the rights of the users in favor of the creators.", I understand the bit about patents.

What I don't get is the DRM bit. Doesn't DRM protect the creator of a work in much the same way as GPLv3 is trying to protect the creator of free software from any type of use? With no DRM, there's no balance between user and creator, just like there's no balance with GPLv2. Before, DRM wasn't necessary, but with new technology, some think it is. Likewise with GPLv3.

I'll make a quick note that I can't stand DRM, but just like if Stallman wants to protect his work (organisation protecting from users like tivo), why shouldn't DRM be viewed the exact same way (record/movie companies protecting from users that steal)?

GregC said...

When it's used to protect copyrighted content such as a movie, I'm thinking it's okay.

When it's used to tie an OS to a given set of hardware... that's another story.

It's theoretically possible to force people to run an OS (case in point Mac OS X) on a given set of hardware using DRM technology.... but then provide the code via the GPL. It defeats the purpose.

Anyway... I'll give a more full answer later, but for now i have to run to work. ;)

GJC

J&D said...

A片下載|成人影片下載|免費A片下載|日本A片|情色A片|免費A片|成人影城|成人電影|線上A片|A片免費看

米蘭情趣用品|情趣用品|情趣|飛機杯|自慰套|充氣娃娃|AV女優.按摩棒|跳蛋|潤滑液|角色扮演|情趣內衣|自慰器|穿戴蝴蝶|變頻跳蛋|無線跳蛋|電動按摩棒|情趣按摩棒|

goodeda1122 said...

自慰套,自慰套,自慰器,情趣,情趣,視訊交友,充氣娃娃,AV,按摩棒,電動按摩棒,情趣按摩棒,按摩棒,跳蛋,跳蛋,跳蛋,男女,潤滑液,SM,情趣內衣,內衣,性感內衣,角色扮演,角色扮演服,吊帶襪,丁字褲,情趣用品,情趣用品,飛機杯,自慰套

Miqdad said...

Find and download that you need at Rapidshare Search Engine.
Top Site Lists Free Proxy Site Free Download mp3 Michael Jackson song All Michael Jackson Lyrics Hollywood Celebrity Gossip Download Mp3 Gratis download naruto download naruto shippuuden windows 7 activator

Adi said...

Oes Tsetnoc one of the ways in which we can learn seo besides Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa. By participating in the Oes Tsetnoc or Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa we can improve our seo skills. To find more information about Oest Tsetnoc please visit my Oes Tsetnoc pages. And to find more information about Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa please visit my Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa pages. Thank you So much.
Oes Tsetnoc | Semangat Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa

s said...

馬桶不通 food forming patty machine boiling machine 化妝品包 裝 紙盒 breading machine vegetable machine日立冷氣 Plastic Drinking Cups宜蘭民宿 宜蘭旅遊教育訓練 品質管理 Ohsas 18001casino gaming machine 泰國清邁 iso認證 iso團體旅遊簽證 slot game machine slot machine cabinet 便宜機票展場設計 二手車 中古車 Bmw 中古車買賣 汽車借款gaming machine manufacturer gaming machine 大陸直航新竹餐廳下午茶特色餐廳景觀餐廳親子餐廳

s said...

彌月禮盒團購美食 印刷 彩色印刷 包裝 設計pe膜 冬令營 food processing equipment frying machine Telecom PCB 泡菜 團購美食油飯麻糬
創業加盟 水餃 壯陽食品 早洩 情趣用品 湯包 DC Jack tact switch Slide switch Phone Jack USB connector RCA Jack開 關 製網 菱形網 不鏽鋼網 金屬網 無塵室射出 Disposable plastic cups Disposable plastic cups Disposable products 宜蘭住宿 ECO products Biodegradable plastic PLA 律師事務所 律師 寵物醫院polylactic acid Biodegradable

s said...

宜蘭民宿 宜蘭住宿 網路訂房 宜蘭飯店 新娘祕書 清潔公司 植牙 裝潢 室內設計 油漆粉刷 油漆工 油漆工程 洗鞋加盟 洗包包加盟 洗包包 創業加盟店 早餐店加盟 開店創業 創業開店 結婚金飾 鑽石婚戒 通水管 通水管 通馬桶 抽水肥 包通 馬桶不通 通馬桶 通水管 清水溝 沙發 室內設計公司 室內設計 室內裝潢設計 裝潢設計 澳門自由行 搬家公司 搬家公司 台北搬家公司 新竹搬家公司 桃園搬家公司 香港自由行太陽能熱水器 三久 櫻花牌熱水器

s said...

seo 網站設計 超耐磨地板 店面出租 乳癌 全身健康檢查 自由行 三久 太陽能 三久太陽能 太陽能熱水器 環保袋 慈善基金會 慈善機構 租辦公室 租店面 買辦公室電波拉皮 hand dryer 電波拉皮 <宜蘭民宿泰國關鍵字廣告 seo seo 線上客服 seo 網頁設計 seo 網頁設計公司
雷射溶脂 肉毒桿菌 系統家具 台中漆彈場 漆彈 團體服 團體服 團體服 T恤 圍裙 網路行銷 中古車 涼麵 POLO衫 班服 團體服創意 熱轉印 團體服訂做

s said...

喜餅價格 訂婚禮盒 訂婚喜餅

s said...

素食月子餐 桃園房屋 桃園房屋網 桃園房屋買賣

My store said...

They are your New Balance for sale , so here at New Balance A20 Navajo ltoona we know new balance 580 for sale that each athlete has different needs, new balance 574 and different feet. We strive to new balance 996 provide the right shoe and a perfect fit for new balance 993 every customer. All athletes understand the new balance 1500 connection between superior new balance 1300 performance and well-fitted shoes - new balance 1400 that's why we carry New Balance 576 sneakers and footwear in a wide new balance 577 variety of sizes and widths so that we can provide the new balance 999 best fit for the best price.

My store said...

Introduced in 1966, Onitsuka Tiger Mexico 66 were the first shoes with the famous Tiger Stripes. ASICS GEL-KINSEI 2 were worn at the Mexico Olympic Games in 1968. With lace up asics gel kinsei 2 sale front and tracks in asics gel kinsei 2 mens the side and suede asics kinsei 2 for sale effect trim on front and back. Purchase Asics Onitsuka Tiger mini cooper and receive onitsuka tiger mini clubman Learn about running shoe types such as motion control, onitsuka tiger mid runner performance training and stability onitsuka tiger mexico 66 mens shoes and discover which type authentic onitsuka tiger shoes sale best fits your pronation type.The original Kinsei was asics gel stratus mens shoes classified by Asics as a asics gel stratus 2.1 for mens Stability+ shoe. The Kinsei II is asics gel stratus 2.1 sale Neutral+ shoe. If you look at the Asics Shoe Fit Chart onitsuka tiger tokidoki mex lo on sale now,every order onitsuka tiger onitsuka tiger california 78 win free shipping,there is no onitsuka tiger fabre 74 other sale tax.you onitsuka tiger fabre can order directly online

My store said...

These shoes made my trip to onitsuka tiger mexico 66 yellow black Argentina that much onitsuka tiger tokidoki mex lo more enjoyable. I needed a pair of onitsuka tiger mexico 66 by asics shoes that I could walk great mens onitsuka tiger mexico 66 distances in and stand in for asics onitsuka tiger mexico 66 several hours at a time. These were my asics gel kinsei 2 answer. They have great support, and give the feeling asics tiger mexico 66 that one is walking on air. They did onitsuka tiger mexico 66 get dirty, when we went rappelling. onitsuka tiger mini clubman Although you are not supposed to, I onitsuka tiger mid runner washed them on gently cycle in my front loader onituka tiger mini cooper washing machine. No harm, no foul. asics gel kinsei 2 mens I highly recommend them.

sarah saad said...




شركة نقل اثاث بالدمام التفاؤل شركة نقل اثاث بالخبر كما انها افضل شركة نقل اثاث بالجبيل نقل عفش واثاث بالجبيل والخبر والقطيف والدمام
شركة نقل اثاث بالدمام
شركة نقل اثاث بالجبيل
شركة نقل اثاث بالقطيف

sarah saad said...



شركة نقل عفش بالمدينة المنورة
شركة نقل عفش بجدة
شركة نقل عفش بمكة
شركة نقل عفش بالطائف
نقل العفش والتخزين